The Word of God is written to a people — but it still looks you in the eye.

It’s become common to point out that the you in the New Testament epistles is plural — written to a body, a church, a people.

So, pulling out the wonderful second person plural we have in Southern English, we’re told we should read it more like this:

For y’all have been saved by grace through faith. And y’all didn’t do it; it is the gift of God. (Ephesians 2:8)

He who began a good work in y’all will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ. (Philippians 1:6)

Now may the God of peace fully sanctify y’all, and may all y’all’s spirit, soul, and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ. (1 Thessalonians 5:23)

Paul isn’t writing to an isolated believer, we’re told, but to a community — to y’all. Fair enough. The point is meant to correct our modern individualism, our tendency to read the Bible as though it were God’s love letter to “me, myself, and I.”

But as with most pendulum swings, the correction can turn into an overcorrection. 

It’s true that modern Western Christians often read Scripture as if it were addressed to a lone individual in a vacuum.

And yes: Christianity is inherently communal, and the faith can’t be lived out apart from the body. Our Good Shepherd doesn’t have free-range sheep. 

But some seem to take the plural “you” as proof that the gospel isn’t really about the individual at all — that salvation, faith, and our grateful obedience are corporate realities only. “It’s not about you; it’s about the church.” And before long, y’all swallows you whole.

That’s where the trouble starts.

When people use the plural “you” to flatten everything into the corporate, they dissolve the person into the group. The pendulum swings from atomized individualism to amorphous collectivism, where the “we” becomes an abstraction that no one actually embodies.

The biblical writers never mean, “You all collectively believe so that no one in particular believes.”

Rather, the plural is distributive — it addresses each person within the community. Every “you (plural)” implies a cluster of yous (singular) who are responsible, comforted, called, and united together.

The NT letters aren’t advocating collectivism in Greek clothing. (Or Jewish clothing either, for all y’all Paul-within-Judaism folks.)

Belonging to the church isn’t being assimilated into the Borg. 

The church is not a blob; it’s a body. And a body is made of living members — connected , but distinct.

If you take away the personal address, you also lose the personal comfort. The gospel that says Christ died for us becomes strangely bloodless if it never reaches the singular: Christ died for you. Paul could speak of Christ loved the church (Ephesians 5:25), but he could also say with just as much wonder, He loved me and gave himself for me (Galatians 2:20). The plural doesn’t cancel the singular; it carries it.

And the same holds true ethically. If everything is corporate, no one repents. “We all fall short” becomes a polite shield for “I’m not owning my sin.” “We” do this, which means I don’t have to.

The remedy for rugged individualism isn’t to erase the individual; it’s to place the individual rightly: individuated in community. [1]

That is, we  are growing into differentiated, mature members of a single body.

• Individualism isolates.
• Collectivism dissolves.
• Individuation-in-community integrates: each person becomes whole in the context of belonging and mutual dependence.

Each person becomes whole not by merging into the mass, but by belonging to the body. The Spirit doesn’t mass-produce generic Christians; He personally forms Christ in each of us, for the sake of all.

Corporately, we are united to Christ as His body, His people, His Bride. Salvation gathers a people. And personally, the same Christ is “for you.” The corporate reality doesn’t erase the personal encounter — it grounds and enlarges it.

To erase the “for you” is to remove the pulse of grace; to erase the “for us” is to remove the body in which that grace breathes.

So yes, the “you” in the New Testament is plural. It’s y’all. But that doesn’t mean you get to hide inside the crowd. It means that every you is drawn into a y’all — and every y’all exists so that you might grow up into Christ, together.

Or to borrow Paul’s grammar:

Y’all are the body of Christ, and individually members of it. (1 Corinthians 12:27)

---

[1] Individualism is rooted in the political, cultural, and moral philosophy of the Enlightenment. It exalts the self’s autonomy, seeking independence, self-sufficiency, and freedom from constraints.  Individuation is an insight drawn from Jungian psychology, describing a natural process of self-realization and transformation. It’s typically seen as a second-half-of-life process, so associated with maturity. Individuation’s goal is to become one’s true self. And that involves community, as relationships with others can reveal hidden depths of the self.